Throughout a fierce contest with fellow American Jessica Pegula, for a moment it seemed that Coco Gauff had discovered her rhythm. Following a tough opening set at the WTA Finals in Riyadh, Gauff dug deep and slowly turned the match in her favor. She reached a crucial point while serving leading 6-5 in the second set.
However, Gauff proceeded to hit three disastrous double faults consecutively, enabling Pegula to reclaim the break without even making contact with a single ball. None of her serves was even remotely close.
This episode clearly highlighted the challenges Gauff faces at the end of an unusual year. In some respects, her professional journey is going supremely well. She secured a second major title at the French Open in June, outsmarting top-ranked Aryna Sabalenka with a win that demonstrated her first slam victory was no fluke. Many assumed reasonable to assume this achievement would build more momentum.
Instead, aside from her title run at the Wuhan Open recently, the last several months have been among the challenging she has faced. Her issues are largely due to one shot: Gauff’s second serve.
Although Gauff has long been susceptible to serving errors, over the past years her service game has fallen apart. According to statistical data, Gauff’s double fault rate, the proportion of service points resulting in errors, is by far the highest among all elite players this year at 9.9%. The second highest rate inside the top ten belongs to Amanda Anisimova, who has an error rate at 6.2%. In a sport, where matches are determined by fine lines, Gauff gives away a tenth of her serves.
During play, Gauff possesses many assets. Her defensive skills and athleticism are unmatched, her two-handed backhand is sublime, and her smarts on the court pair well with her versatile game. While her forehand shot can be inconsistent, all evidence points to the performance of her second serve will likely determine how high she can go professionally. She tops the circuit for return games won, securing 46.8% when returning this year, and she has won a respectable 68.6% on first serves, ranking her at No 12 among the best.
Her problems begin with her second serve. She ranks as the sixth worst player inside the top 50 for second serve points won currently. Not counting serving errors, however, she has won the second best percentage on second serves on the tour. Should she lower her service errors, her results will improve significantly.
Following a painful series of serving performances by Gauff this summer, featuring 23 double faults against Danielle Collins at Montreal, she finally made a big change. Just prior to the US Open, the American split from her coach Matt Daly opting for bringing in tennis biomechanics specialist Gavin MacMillan. They immediately, they implemented significant changes to her “hitchy” service technique, especially her knee flexion and her tendency to drop her head down, as she tries to create speed on her racket which often leads to her finishing off balance.
A top player undertaking such a major change in coaches just before a major tournament is almost unheard of and it made for a miserable week in New York. Following tears during play in her second round victory against Donna Vekic and facing intense scrutiny, Gauff lost in round four by Naomi Osaka.
The decision to wait until after the US Open to make such major changes, however, also showed a lot about her mindset. She holds the third spot and has played among the best of professional tennis for half a decade. It’s often difficult to concentrate on future improvements while a competitor faces expectations to win almost every time. However, she remains just 21, and she should continue focusing on improving as a player. Gauff evidently gets this.
In spite of the loss to Pegula, Gauff still holds the chance to advance from the group stages of the WTA Finals, as the the defending champion. However, how her game evolves going forward is far more important. An obvious point of reference is Aryna Sabalenka, whose service was problematic previously.
Many times back in 2022, struggling with her second service, Sabalenka opted for using underhand second services. This year, her error rate at 3.1% is the third lowest among the top players. It will take a while for Coco to determine if her work with MacMillan will also yield permanent gains, but, if they are just half as effective as the top player in the world, she can expect many more big titles to come.